Fellow’s Corner – A Career as a Cathodic Protection Engineer

This series of articles is intended to highlight industry wide engineering experiences, practical opinions, guidance, and focused advice to practising technologists. The series is written by ICorr Fellows who have made significant contributions to the field of corrosion management. The articles in this issue feature contributions from David Harvey, who gives a personal view of his career as a senior CP Engineer, and Douglas Mills, who discusses the use of Electrochemical Noise Measurement in determining corrosion.

A Career as a Cathodic Protection Engineer

This article highlights some aspects of an interesting and rewarding career in the cathodic protection industry and with the Institute of Corrosion. It aims to show what can be experienced within the workplace and outside of it, in a varied, fascinating and satisfying career over 50 years gained with consultants, oil and gas operators, cathodic protection companies and engineering design houses. Hopefully this will encourage newcomers to the industry that there is great career to be had in cathodic protection.

I, like many others, came into cathodic protection by accident. I joined a CP Specialist Consulting Engineering Company as a draughtsman while still completing my day-release HNC in Electrical Engineering. I was fortunate to have an excellent mentor in David Lewis, former ICorr President, who gave me John Morgan’s “Cathodic Protection” textbook to study. I progressed on to become a CP design engineer. As I did not drive at that time and site visits were limited, I benefitted from picking the brains of my colleagues’ knowledge and site experience, as back then, junior engineers were teamed up with a senior engineer to learn their trade, which regrettably does not happen today. However, one of the enlightening aspects about the CP Industry is that senior engineers are generally very open in sharing their knowledge and experiences – both good and bad – to enable us to continually improve the way we approach projects and produce more cost effective, efficient designs.

CP Engineers come from many different disciplines (e.g. mechanical, electrical, chemical, civil etc) some from grass roots and others from universities. The application of CP to structures requires detailed interaction with all disciplines so one ends up knowing a little about a lot, rather than a lot about a little, unless specialising in one particular area. Rarely are two projects identical as there are so many different parameters to be considered. Today, there are training courses, exams and certification offered by ICorr at all levels from Tester to Senior Design Engineer (Levels 1- 4 of ISO 15257). However, CP is something you also need to learn from field experience – often by trial and error. It is not something you can just study and apply effectively from a desk alone. Design spreadsheets can often contain errors or have bad data inputted so the output needs strong experience to know if it is sound or “rubbish”.

My practical experience was initially gained by secondment to Middle Eastern oil companies. It covered applying cathodic protection to oil and gas fields, pipelines, associated tankage, and marine facilities. This was a very exciting time for a young man who had not previously been out of the UK. Working in the desert oil fields was almost like being on Safari. On return to UK, I was appointed a CP project engineer. Over time, I moved up to Engineering Manager and Consultant in a number of cathodic protection companies, design houses and as an independent consultant.

I was responsible for all aspects of sacrificial anode and major ICCP systems for pipelines, refineries/petrochemical facilities, and inshore/offshore marine structure projects.

My career as a cathodic protection engineer has given me the opportunity to visit and work in more than 25 different countries and meet many exceptional people at all levels. Occasionally, one could find sufficient spare time to visit some of the local tourist attractions, e.g. various roman ruins, Great Wall of China, Great Pyramids, Panama Canal etc. which were very enjoyable benefits I would not have otherwise gained.

ICorr Activities
As the industry expanded in the 1980’s, I became involved in ICorr activities when they had the Joint Venture with NACE (CCEJV), which became the Corrosion Engineering Association (CEA).

Initially, I joined a CCEJV cathodic protection work group to assist with the preparation of a State-of-the-Art Report to be published by ICorr and NACE. This enabled me to learn from my peers and, at the same time, put some of my experience back into the industry for the younger engineers to benefit from. Later, I became Work-Group Chair, then Task-Group Chair. I was then appointed Technical Activities Coordinating Committee (TACC) Chair. This role also included being the Conference Programme Manager for “UK Corrosion” which was a major three-day event in the corrosion world 1987-1991. As TACC Chair, I also attended NACE Committee Weeks and Corrosion Conferences in USA as the UK ICorr/CCEJV representative. This was a tremendous opportunity for interaction with cathodic protection engineers and manufacturers from around the world. Regrettably, after much good work, NACE and ICorr parted company in 1988 and the CEA became the Corrosion Engineering Division of ICorr.

I also became the representative for Pipeline Industries Guild and the Institute of Petroleum on the BSI CP GEL 603 committee in 1985 which was revising the UK CP bible, BS CP1021. This was eventually published as BS7361 in 1991. In 1993 I was elected to chair this committee, a post I held for the next 19 years, coordinating the UK input into numerous BS/CEN CP standards prepared and published during this time.

Apart from the BSI committee, I also became involved in various ICorr committees and Council:
• Member of Council 1998-Present.
• Chair of Professional Assessment Committee 1998 – 2012.
• Chair of CP Certification Sub-Committee 2006-2019.
• Chair of Course Approvals Board 2013-2019.
• Member of CP Governing Board (2002- 2020).
• QA Advisor attaining ISO 9001 Certification.
• ICorr Representative for UK to CEOCOR (2008 – 2012).
• Professional Affiliate Engineering Council Coordinator with Society of Operations Engineers – current role.
• Primary author/updater of 5 ICorr CP training Courses to ISO 15257 for On-land and Marine Structures.

As a result of these activities, I was awarded Honorary Fellow Member of ICorr in 2018.

One of the other milestones in my career was attaining Professional Affiliate Status for ICorr with the Engineering Council. This was followed by the setting up a Registration Agreement with the Society of Environment Engineers enabling suitably qualified and experienced members to apply for registration with the Engineering Council as a CEng, IEng or EngTech. Having set the system up, I thought I should be the guinea pig to try it out. My application was successful and I was awarded CEng. With the demise of SEE, I set up a new Registration Agreement with the Society of Operations Engineers.

As a result, more than 50 of our members have become registered as Chartered Engineers – a tremendous benefit available for our professional members.

In Conclusion
As I look back over the last 50+ years, I can reflect on the many good memories of a varied career, the many friends and colleagues I have worked with and the opportunities I was given to expand my knowledge. I have tried to put back some of this for young engineers to consider that a career in CP can be very interesting and rewarding. To be honest, I still get satisfaction from it and in retirement, I am still dabbling, doing some CP design appraisals/approvals. A long and interesting, satisfying career in CP is very achievable albeit with a lot of hard work.
David Harvey CEng, FICorr(Hon)

A Cathodic Protection Engineer at work.

ICorr Coating Inspection Level 1, 2 and 3 certificate renewal online

ICorr Coating Inspection Level 1, 2 and 3 certificate renewal online

Course Overview

Renewal Application: To initiate the renewal process, please select the qualification that you would like to renew and ensure that all the required information is accurately filled out.

ICorr level 1 – £350.00

ICorr level 2 – £350.00

ICorr level 3 – £350.00

Insulation Coating Inspector
Pipeline Coating Inspector
Hot Dip Galvanising Inspector

Course Review

We recommend reviewing the course material to refresh your knowledge. We will provide you with 1-month access. Existing Corrodere Academy students can access the material using their login credentials.

Renewal Exam: The exam consists of 40 multiple-choice questions conducted online. A passing score is 70% or higher.

 

Renewal fee

£275 – £350
Plus 20% VAT if applicable

Course and examination enquiries

For any questions or further enquiries, please visit our training partner’s website at www.corrodere.com alternatively you can contact them on:

+44 (0) 1252 732236
info@corrodere.com

Standards Up-date  ISO

Standards Up-date ISO

The following documents have obtained substantial support during
the past two months and have been submitted to the ISO member bodies for formal approval.

ISO/PRF 1461 Hot dip galvanized coatings on fabricated iron and steel articles — Specifications and test methods (Revision of 2009 standard)

ISO/FDIS 4215 Corrosion of metals and alloys —Test method for high-temperature corrosion testing of metallic materials by thermogravimetry under isothermal or cyclic conditions

ISO/DIS 4905 Corrosion of metals and alloys— Electrochemical test methods— Guideline for electrochemical measurements in high temperature molten salts

ISO/DIS 18115-1 Surface chemical analysis — Vocabulary — Part 1: General terms and terms used in spectroscopy (Revision of 2013 standard)

ISO/FDIS 24139-1 Petroleum and natural gas industries — Corrosion resistant alloy clad bends and fittings for pipeline transportation system —Part 1: Clad bends
New International standards published in the past two months

ISO/TR 4340:2022 Water aggressiveness evaluation and optimized lining choice

ISO 12696:2022 Cathodic protection of steel in concrete

ISO 18768-1:2022 Organic coatings on aluminium and its alloys — Methods for specifying decorative and protective organic coatings on aluminium — Part 1: Powder coatings

ISO 18768-2:2022 Organic coatings on aluminium and its alloys — Methods for specifying decorative and protective organic coatings on aluminium — Part 2: Liquid coatings

ISO 24656:2022 Cathodic protection of offshore wind Structures

Water transport through epoxy-based powder pipeline coatings

The water permeation kinetics of two common epoxy-based powder coating systems for pipelines across a range of industrially-relevant temperatures (from room temperature to 80 °C) has been studied. The nonlinear dependency of water transport on the vapour concentration at 65 °C was also analysed. The vapour transport analysis of epoxy coatings demonstrated a turning point around this temperature, perhaps due to clustering of water molecules. At higher temperatures, break-up of water clusters and plasticisation of the polymer expedited the transport.

The researchers also examined microstructural changes of the epoxy network due to water transport and found evidence for irreversible damage to epoxy coatings under hydrothermal exposures. It appears that the combination of thermal exposure and internal stresses in the glassy epoxy leads to a phase separation of filler particles from the epoxy matrix, as well as to a distinctive cavity formation in the coating membrane. The results indicate that hydrothermal exposure is likely to increase aggregate porosity of the coating. Analysis of wet-state permeation is not only crucial for protection of transport pipelines, but it also is of high relevance to process equipment and underground storage tanks.

The study was published in Progress in Organic Coatings, Volume 168, July 2022.

Optimisation of adhesion to improve steel corrosion protection

Optimisation of adhesion to improve steel corrosion protection

A new study focused on the possibility of using siloxane resins with epoxy modification to delay corrosion of metal substrates for hydraulic applications.

Formulations aimed at metal protection were designed, without including anticorrosive additives, and deposited on 11SMnPb37 steel. Thin monolayer films were obtained by dip coating in different process conditions, avoiding primers. The developed procedure was simple and able to provide solid and well-anchored coatings. They were characterised in terms of morphology, scratch and wear endurance, and resistance to a corrosive environment. The optimum formulation and deposition parameters were determined and the selected coating showed remarkable adhesion to the substrate, good mechanical properties, and resistance in a saline environment, proving to be suitable as a protective barrier against corrosion. The protective effect was ensured not by additives but through the excellent adhesion of the coating and its endurance to scratch and wear.